What is the theory of constraints (TOC)?
Tempo Team
The theory of constraints (TOC) is a project management methodology introduced by Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt that identifies and addresses the most limiting factors (aka constraints) that hinder an organization’s ability to achieve its goals. The concept is founded on the premise that any system – whether a manufacturing process, project, or organization – is only as strong as its weakest link.
TOC provides tools and strategies to strengthen that link, systematically addressing bottlenecks and improving overall performance. According to Goldratt, the ultimate goal of TOC is to minimize the number of constraints in a system. By doing so, an organization can operate more efficiently, respond to changes more effectively, and continuously improve its outcomes.
TOC promotes a focused approach that concentrates resources and efforts on overcoming these critical setbacks to maximize results.
What are constraints in project management?
In project management, constraints are factors that limit a project’s execution and impact its success. Constraints represent the conditions under which a project must be completed. They’re essential considerations for project managers during planning and execution.
An important concept in understanding constraints is the “project management triangle,” also known as the “triple constraint.” This model illustrates the interplay between three fundamental constraints that influence every project:
Scope constraint: This constraint defines what work must be done, including project deliverables and requirements. Changes to scope can affect time and cost.
Time constraint: Refers to the project schedule, including deadlines for individual tasks and overall completion.
Cost constraint: Encompasses the project budget, including all financial resources allocated to the project.
The project management triangle demonstrates that altering one constraint impacts the others. For example, increasing scope might require more time or a larger budget, whereas reducing time could lead to higher costs or limited deliverables. Balancing these constraints is a core challenge of effective project management.
Sign up for a demo
RegisterWhat is the goal of the theory of constraints?
Goldratt’s theory of constraints identifies and manages constraints within a system. Its project management methodologies enable organizations to systematically address their most significant bottlenecks, improving performance and creating continuous growth. The following are essential elements of TOC:
The five focusing steps: A step-by-step process to identify and address constraints.
The thinking processes: Logical tools used to analyze and resolve complex problems.
Throughput accounting: A performance measurement system focused on maximizing the rate of achieving a goal.
Buffer management: A technique to protect the system from variability by strategically managing resources and time buffers.
Theory of constraints: The 5 focusing steps
The theory of constraints’ five steps provide a clear roadmap to effectively manage constraints. These steps create a framework for improving system performance by individually addressing the most critical limiting factors. The steps are as follows:
Identify constraints: The first step is pinpointing the system’s most significant bottlenecks. Constraints can be physical (e.g., equipment or resources) or non-physical (e.g., policies or procedures).
Exploit constraints: Once identified, the constraint should be optimized to perform at its maximum potential. This step ensures processes account for the bottleneck without interruptions or inefficiencies.
Subordinate other activities: Align all other processes to support the constraint. No other activity should overpower or disrupt the bottleneck’s output.
Elevate constraints: If the constraint remains a limiting factor after optimization, additional resources or investments may be necessary to eliminate the bottleneck.
Repeat the process: After resolving one constraint, another may emerge. TOC is a continuous improvement cycle, so the process should be repeated to identify and address all constraints.
The thinking processes
The theory of constraints offers tools called “the thinking processes” to solve complex problems. These tools guide decision-making by breaking down challenges into manageable parts to help find practical solutions. The thinking processes help answer three essential questions:
What needs to change? Identify the issue or obstacle that is preventing progress.
What should it be changed to? Define the ideal solution to address the problem.
How to cause the change? Determine the actions required to move from the current state to the desired outcome.
The following are the primary thinking processes in the theory of constraints:
The Current Reality Tree (CRT): A tool used to map out the existing problem that shows how different issues are connected and identifies the root cause.
The Evaporating Cloud (EC): A method to resolve dilemmas by challenging underlying assumptions and finding win-win solutions.
The Future Reality Tree (FRT): A visualization of the desired outcome, showing how changes will lead to a better system or resolution of the problem.
The Prerequisite Tree (PRT): A step-by-step guide for identifying and addressing obstacles that must be overcome to achieve the desired outcome.
The Transition Tree (TT): A detailed plan that outlines specific actions needed to move from the current situation to the desired future state.
Throughput accounting
Throughput accounting is a method of measuring performance and managing finances within the framework of the theory of constraints. Unlike standard accounting methods, it focuses on how decisions impact the system’s overall goal, such as generating profit or delivering value.
The throughput accounting method comprises three core measures that reflect how resources contribute to desired outcomes:
Throughput: The rate at which the system generates money through sales. It is calculated as revenue minus the variable costs associated with producing the goods or services sold. Throughput emphasizes actual output rather than projections.
Operating expenses: These are the total costs required to run the system, excluding variable costs tied directly to production. This includes salaries, rent, utilities, and other fixed expenses.
Investment: This is the money tied up in assets the system uses to produce throughput, such as inventory, equipment, facilities, and other resources necessary for operations.
Throughput accounting shows how each of these measures interacts. It guides decisions to avoid failure and maximize the system’s success by focusing on constraints and their impact on profitability.
Buffer management
The theory of constraints uses buffers to protect the system from disruptions and maintain a steady workflow. Buffers act as safeguards to ensure variations or delays in one part of the process do not negatively impact the entire system.
One of the most significant buffers in the theory of constraints is the drum-buffer-rope system. This method coordinates the flow of work through the system by addressing the constraint directly:
Drum: Represents the constraint, setting the tempo for the entire system. All activities are synchronized to match the drum’s capacity so that no resources are wasted.
Buffer: Protects the drum from delays by ensuring it always has the necessary inputs to keep working efficiently. This buffer helps prevent interruptions in the system’s critical point.
Rope: Controls the release of work into the system, establishing that no more work enters than the drum can handle. This avoids overloading the constraint, minimizes bottlenecks, and balances workflow.
Combining the theory of constraints and lean manufacturing
The theory of constraints and lean manufacturing can work together to optimize processes and enhance productivity. While the theory of constraints identifies and manages the most limiting factor in a system, lean manufacturing reduces waste and increases efficiency. Together, they massively improve overall performance.
When businesses combine lean manufacturing practices with the theory of constraints, they can create more flexible and resilient systems. The following tools and methods from lean manufacturing complement the theory of constraints:
Eliminate waste with 5S and Kaizen: The 5S system organizes workspaces to improve efficiency and reduce clutter, whereas Kaizen promotes ongoing efforts to identify and eliminate waste. These tools bolster TOC’s goal of supporting the constraint by freeing up resources and removing unnecessary steps.
Continuous improvement with PDCA: The Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) cycle provides a structured method for testing and implementing improvements. With it, you can evaluate solutions to alleviate constraints and ensure sustained progress.
Value stream mapping: This tool visualizes the entire workflow, highlighting bottlenecks and illustrating their impact on the system.
Standardized work: Consistent procedures lead to greater efficiency, minimized variability, and reduced risk of introducing new bottlenecks which could tax the constraint.
Navigate the theory of constraints with Tempo
Roadmaps are invaluable for managing and tracking multiple projects at once, especially in areas like IT, product development, and project management. They provide a clear overview of progress, align priorities across teams, and foster better organization and collaboration. By visualizing tasks and timelines, roadmaps help teams stay focused on their priorities, including effectively managing constraints.
Tempo helps you create clear, centralized roadmaps that prioritize ideas, track progress, and organize your projects. Ready to get started? Discover how Tempo’s Strategic Roadmaps can take your projects to the next level.
