Tempo logotype
Agile at Scale7 min read

Shaking up the status quo: Agile vs. waterfall approaches

There are pros and cons on both sides of the waterfall versus agile divide. Here’s how to choose the right methodology for your project.
From Team '23

Tempo Team

With the popularity of the agile project management methodology, it might seem like there’s no room for old-school approaches, such as the waterfall model. That couldn’t be further from the truth. 

Although 71% of software development companies use agile management techniques like Kanban and Scrum to facilitate iterative development, there’s still a place for linear approaches, like the waterfall method

The key to a successful outcome often depends on your project management methodology. Choosing the correct technique requires understanding the differences between waterfall versus agile and when you should implement one approach over the other. 

What is agile methodology?

Software development project teams were the first to establish and embrace the agile model, which accounts for the fast pace of technological change and the protracted length of their projects. Developers needed a management methodology with the flexibility to accommodate shifts in direction throughout the software development life cycle (SLDC), even in its final stages.  

The iterative and incremental nature of agile-based project development promotes adaptability, allowing teams to adjust requirements and outputs based on client and user input. Unlike a sequential development path, the Agile Manifesto prescribes a regular release cycle of product updates and new features, delivering successive quick wins and ongoing product improvements.  

Teams that follow agile principles are self-directed, organizing their own work into phases with concurrent tasks and short-term deadlines. The arrangement empowers team members, increasing overall motivation and improving outcomes for stakeholders and the organization. 

Pros of agile methodology

Thanks to the operational structure of the agile process, it offers many benefits to project teams, including:

  • Improved productivity and efficiency driven by short-term sprints and deadlines

  • Opportunities to detect and solve problems early on a fluid schedule

  • The flexibility to experiment with new project directions

  • Prioritization of high-value features

  • Cross-functional project teams with a shared skill set

  • A client-facing process that lets teams share progress and incorporate feedback

  • Improved relationships and connections

  • Faster time to market

  • Increased customer satisfaction

Cons of the agile methodology

Although the benefits of the agile approach are significant, there are substantial shortcomings to this development process:

  • Adjustments to early stages can impact later ones when working on multiple project phases simultaneously, increasing the probability of overlap and effort duplication

  • Alignment across teams and departments is difficult without concrete deliverables

  • Increased risk of miscommunication

  • Project timelines are difficult to calculate and susceptible to change

  • Poorly defined critical path and inter-project dependencies

  • Significant organizational learning curve

  • Agile’s continuous iteration pipeline involves significant engineering costs and technical dependencies

What is waterfall methodology?

Waterfall project management follows linear, sequential task execution within five defined project phases:

  1. Initiation

  2. Project planning

  3. Execution

  4. Monitoring/control

  5. Closing

Team members must finish each development stage and gain approval before moving to the next. A change in scope or missed deadline causes a ripple effect impacting future phases. 

The waterfall model’s limitations mean it requires meticulous project planning. The scope must be clearly outlined, the dependencies mapped, and the schedule padded to accommodate any risks or challenges. The project manager takes the lead, ensuring effective time management and overseeing a change control process to minimize scope creep.  

The rigidity of the waterfall methodology makes it difficult and expensive to revisit a previous project stage. Its inflexible schedule and resource allocation prevent the team from switching gears in the face of unforeseen developments. This could leave the project susceptible to technical debt or cause the product to lose market share.

Pros of waterfall methodology

Despite its shortcomings, the waterfall project management methodology can prove useful. Under specific circumstances, the model offers some significant advantages over the agile method:

  • Yields a concrete project plan with clearly defined dependencies throughout

  • Saves the project manager’s time by outlining project requirements at the start

  • Project phases divided into concrete deliverables require less hands-on coordination

  • Allows for more accurate cost estimates

  • Increases focus on design and requirement documentation

  • Institutes a structured design phase before software development begins

Cons of waterfall methodology

Along with the lack of adaptability, the waterfall development methodology has additional drawbacks:

  • Project delivery takes longer due to the sequential development lifecycle

  • Teams require additional communication overhead during phase transitions

  • Strict phase sequences make dividing and sharing work between teams difficult

  • The lack of feedback may delay the discovery of a mistake until the team progresses to the next development phase, obscuring where and when the error occurred

  • Delayed transition to the next phase can waste time and set back deliverables

  • Lower cross-functionality necessitates additional staff to fill the skill gap

  • Focus on the current phase rather than the complete package reduces team ownership and engagement

Agile vs. waterfall: Primary differences

The decision to work as a waterfall or agile team carries significant implications for your project and customers. Here’s a side-by-side comparison:

Waterfall or agile: What’s right for you?

Agile’s fast-moving iterations, user stories, and increased flexibility might be attractive, but is it the right choice for your team? Or would you benefit from a highly structured, linear process that maps the entire process ahead of time?

Those are tough questions. You must review the project’s characteristics to see whether it demands the waterfall or the agile methodology.  

Waterfall projects

Waterfall management suits well-defined, straightforward projects with established requirements and an explicit timeline. The waterfall model works best for projects with these traits:

  • Simple scope and requirement gathering

  • Accommodate a linear sequence

  • Predictable results

  • Structured workflow and process

  • Rigorous quality control

  • Long-term commitment

Agile projects

The agile project management model supports initiatives with abstract outcomes and those requiring numerous feedback loops.

Agile software development is particularly effective because it permits iterations and frequent testing as the team moves forward. It’s also a helpful methodology when working with dispersed teams requiring intense collaboration.

Consider an agile method when your project meets the following criteria:

  • Complex deliverables

  • Regular iterations and refinement

  • Short turn-around time on deliverables

  • Emerging product requirements

  • Collaborative effort

  • Numerous stakeholders

Conclusion

No matter the project management methodology, you need the right tools for the job. Jira project management software is the go-to application for most agile teams, allowing scrum masters to create Kanban boards, manage backlogs, and organize sprints. But this doesn’t mean you’re left out in the cold if you favor the waterfall approach. 

Tempo Structure, a portfolio management application, integrates into Jira so you can organize projects using a linear structure similar to the waterfall methodology you’re familiar with. 

You can leverage other Jira-enabled Tempo applications, such as Strategic Roadmaps and Timesheets, whether operating under agile or waterfall. The Strategic Roadmaps application simplifies project planning by generating intuitive project road maps that help teams identify critical paths, task dependencies, and roadblocks. Tempo Timesheets facilitates time and resource use monitoring, so you’re always on track to meet your goals and objectives

Whatever your project management tool requirements, Tempo has the solution. 

Sign up for a demo

Register

Explore More Content

Strategic Portfolio Management

Strategic Portfolio Management

Modern modular PPM solutions that scale with your business. Align your teams with the integrated platform that bridges the gap between strategy and execution.

Learn more

Jira ITSM Solutions with Tempo

ITSM

Build and scale a custom ITSM solution at your own pace with Tempo's modular suite of integrated tools. Enhance Jira's capabilities and take control of your entire IT portfolio.

Learn more

Jira Portfolio Management PPM

Structure by Tempo

Jira Project Portfolio Management (PPM): Visualize data and manage projects within spreadsheet-like tables — in less than a minute

Go to marketplace

Agile at Scale Software

Agile at Scale

Adapt to changing business needs, rapidly adjust plans, and reallocate investment.

Learn more

Project and program management for Jira

Structure PPM

Visualize all your Jira data & manage portfolios of projects in real-time.

Learn more

Jira Project Cost Tracking

Financial Manager

Project financial management for Jira & Timesheets. Monitor project costs, expenses, revenue, billing & budgets. Track Capex/Opex

Go to marketplace

Custom charts and dashboards for Jira

Custom Charts for Jira

See how work is progressing and where blockers are with the most flexible reporting app in Jira.

Learn more

Take control of your projects

Integration: Portfolio Manager and Jira

Portfolio Manager integrates seamlessly with Jira to give you predictive scheduling, real-time scenario modeling, and advanced resource management – ensuring you stay on track, no matter what challenges arise.

Learn more

No-Code Power BI Jira Integration

Power BI Connector for Jira

Effortlessly bridge Jira with your preferred BI tool, unlocking unparalleled insights and enhancing decision-making

Learn more

Unified time and team management

Integration: Timesheets and Structure

Combining Tempo Timesheets and Structure PPM provides a unified view of time tracking and project progress, enabling more accurate reporting and effective portfolio management. Simplify workflows, enhance collaboration, and ensure projects stay on time and within budget.

Learn more

AI-enabled capacity visualization

Capacity Insights - Open Beta

Deliver visibility into how your team's time and efforts align with business objectives and project ROI - without the manual effort

Learn more

Real-time collaboration and capacity planning in Jira

Capacity Planner

A powerful team resource management tool designed to optimize capacity planning and project management in Jira

Learn more

Monitor financial health at every level

Financial Manager for Timesheets

Monitor projects and portfolios to get simple, clear, and real-time views of your costs, budgets, and profits that can be shared throughout your entire organization.

Learn more

Jira Team & Resource Management

Capacity Planner

#1 Jira Resource Management App: Optimize team allocation, skillset utilization, capacity planning & project management

Go to marketplace

Jira Time Tracking

Timesheets by Tempo

#1 Jira Time Tracking & AI Apps: Log Tempo Timesheets for Planning, Project Management & Billing. Plugin Office365, Google & Slack

Go to marketplace

Time Tracking Software for Jira

Timesheets

Tempo’s intuitive automation and Jira-native design make it the most trusted time tracking tool for enterprise organization.

Learn more

Unified time and team management

Integration: Timesheets and Capacity Planner

Seamlessly manage project timelines and resources while accurately tracking time spent on tasks. This integration enhances visibility, improves planning accuracy, and supports data-driven decision-making for better overall project outcomes.

Learn more

Align your organization with proactive portfolio management

Portfolio Manager (LiquidPlanner)

Predictive scheduling and the ability to forecast project timelines and spot risks so you can meet deadlines with confidence.

Learn more

Centralize real-time plans in one view

Integration: Structure and Gantt Charts

Gain a more complete project management solution, simplifying project reporting, improving collaboration, and ensuring projects stay on time and within budget.

Learn more